Whitehall Apartment Corporation: Your Upper West Side Rental Resource

Whitehall Apartment Corporation Introduce

Finding the right apartment to rent in New York City is a journey that goes beyond just location and price. It's about finding a place that feels like home, managed by a team that ensures your comfort and safety. Whitehall Apartment Corporation, situated in a historic pre-war building on the Upper West Side, is a real estate rental agency that operates within this dynamic market. The building, known as Whitehall Apartments, is a fifteen-story structure with a mix of studio and one-bedroom units, each with its own unique design. This agency serves as the management and rental hub for this property, aiming to provide a living experience that combines classic charm with the needs of a modern New Yorker.

The resident experience, however, is often a mix of positives and negatives, as evidenced by a detailed review from a resident. This review points to a significant deterioration in the building's management and environment over the last year. The reviewer notes multiple issues that are crucial for any potential renter to be aware of, including two instances of water leaks in their bathroom, one of which involved "toilet water." The lack of a proper apology from management for such a serious issue is a key point of concern raised by the resident. This highlights the importance of clear communication and accountability in a landlord-tenant relationship, especially in a city where such issues can be a major source of stress.

Another significant issue raised in the review is related to noise. The resident specifically warns against renting apartments that face the sundeck due to "unbearable" noise from partying, which includes "alcohol, smoke, and loud screaming" from early morning until 10 p.m. This is compounded by the resident's claim that management "does nothing to address complaints" and that trying to solve the problem could result in a "threatening letter." This points to a potential issue with managing tenant behavior and a lack of responsiveness to complaints, which are critical factors for a quality living environment. The reviewer also mentions street noise from a trash truck at a nearby diner, a common urban issue that light sleepers should be aware of.

Pest problems were also a concern, with the resident noting an increase in large and small bugs, and flies, especially during the summer. While pest issues can affect any urban building, a significant increase suggests a potential lapse in maintenance or management protocols. Furthermore, the reviewer details what they perceive as disrespectful and "belittling" treatment by the male managers towards a "young Asian female." This is a serious allegation that raises questions about the professional conduct and inclusiveness of the management team. While the reviewer notes that the maintenance workers are "very kind and helpful," they also express concern about their working conditions, suggesting that they may be "heavily exploited."

Whitehall Apartment Corporation is located at 250 W 100th St c104, New York, NY 10025, USA, placing it in a prime Upper West Side location. The building is situated between Broadway and West End Avenue, putting residents within blocks of some of the area's finest restaurants, shops, parks, and entertainment venues. The location is also within walking distance of Columbia University, making it a potentially convenient option for students and faculty.

The accessibility of this address is a major advantage. It is conveniently located near the 1, 2, 3, B, and C subway lines, offering residents quick and easy access to different parts of Manhattan and the city. This excellent transit access is a key selling point for any New York rental. The proximity to Riverside Park and Central Park also provides significant lifestyle benefits, offering residents a chance to enjoy green spaces and recreational activities just a short walk from their front door.

Services Offered

Apartment Rentals: As a real estate rental agency, their primary function is to lease and manage studio and one-bedroom apartments in their building.
Property Management: They are responsible for the day-to-day management of the building, including maintenance, resident relations, and administrative tasks.
Leasing and Renewals: Handling all aspects of the rental process, from showing available units and processing applications to managing lease agreements and renewals.
Tenant Support: While the provided review is negative, the stated goal of such agencies is to provide support to tenants for various needs, including maintenance requests and addressing complaints.
Building Maintenance: Overseeing the upkeep and maintenance of the building, including repairs to common areas and individual units.

Features / Highlights

Historic Pre-War Building: The building features classic architectural charm with unique layouts, which is a desirable feature for many New York renters.
Prime Upper West Side Location: The address is in a highly sought-after neighborhood, with excellent access to restaurants, shops, parks, and cultural attractions.
Convenient Transportation: The building is located near multiple subway lines and bus routes, making it easy for residents to commute and explore the city.
Unique Unit Features: Apartments offer classic elements like hardwood floors and marble bathrooms, combining historic character with modern living.
On-site Management: The presence of an on-site management team is intended to provide direct and timely support to residents.

Contact Information

Address: 250 W 100th St c104, New York, NY 10025, USA

Phone: (212) 222-9009

What is worth choosing

Choosing a rental property in New York requires careful consideration, and the detailed review of the Whitehall Apartment Corporation highlights several critical factors for any prospective tenant. While the building's prime location on the Upper West Side and its historic, charming pre-war architecture are undeniable benefits, the negative experiences shared by a resident are significant. Issues with unresponsive management, unresolved maintenance problems, disruptive noise, and allegations of disrespectful treatment are major red flags that any potential renter should investigate thoroughly. These are not minor inconveniences but rather issues that can significantly impact a person's quality of life and sense of safety.

For a potential tenant, the location and the building's aesthetic appeal may be a strong draw. The proximity to parks, restaurants, and public transportation is an undeniable asset for city living. However, the quality of life within the building, as described in the review, must be weighed against these benefits. It is highly advisable for anyone considering an apartment managed by this corporation to take a proactive approach. This could include requesting to speak with current or past tenants, visiting the property multiple times at different hours to assess noise levels, and asking direct questions to management about their policies on maintenance, pest control, and handling tenant complaints. In a competitive rental market, a discerning renter understands that a beautiful facade and a great location are only part of the equation; the professionalism and responsiveness of the management team are equally, if not more, important for a positive and long-term living experience.

Whitehall Apartment Corporation Photos

No photos available at the moment.

Whitehall Apartment Corporation Location

Whitehall Apartment Corporation

New York New York County New York West 100th Street

250 W 100th St c104, New York, NY 10025, USA

Whitehall Apartment Corporation Reviews

An average rating of ★3.5 from 11 user reviews.

buildingpests

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I’ve lived here for almost two years, and I must say that the management and overall environment of the building have deteriorated significantly since last year:1. Water Leaks: I've experienced two instances of water leaking in my bathroom from the apartment above (with toilet water). I was very understanding and didn't ask for any compensation, yet I never received a proper apology from management.2. Noise Issues: I strongly advise against renting apartments that overlook the sundeck. While they may seem appealing with an extra window, the noise from partying neighbors (from early morning until 10 p.m.)—including alcohol, smoke, and loud screaming—can be unbearable. Occasionally, even the building manager joins in on the noise. Management does nothing to address complaints, and if you try to stop the noise, you might receive a threatening letter accusing you of harassing other residents. (Note: The sundeck was closed for construction during my first year but reopened last summer.)3. Pest Problems: During my first year, there were hardly any pests. However, last summer, I began seeing large ones, followed by frequent small bugs and flies. Some can even be spotted in the basement.4. Street Noise: If possible, avoid apartments facing the street, though most of them do. The trash truck from the Metro Diner makes loud noise every night around 1-2 a.m. If you’re a light sleeper, be prepared for disrupted sleep.5. Disrespectful Treatment: If you are a young Asian female, be prepared to be treated with disrespect and a belittling attitude by the managers. The way the two male managers speak to you is not like addressing a customer, but more like speaking to "a little girl”6. Most of the maintenance workers I’ve encountered in the building over the past years have been very kind and helpful. However, I must note that some of them seem to be heavily exploited, working excessively long hours with little to no rest. I’m not entirely sure if their working conditions are fully legal.
February 08 · D L
I’ve lived here for almost two years, and I must say that the management and overall environment of the building have deteriorated significantly since last year:1. Water Leaks: I've experienced two instances of water leaking in my bathroom from the apartment above (with toilet water). I was very understanding and didn't ask for any compensation, yet I never received a proper apology from management.2. Noise Issues: I strongly advise against renting apartments that overlook the sundeck. While they may seem appealing with an extra window, the noise from partying neighbors (from early morning until 10 p.m.)—including alcohol, smoke, and loud screaming—can be unbearable. Occasionally, even the building manager joins in on the noise. Management does nothing to address complaints, and if you try to stop the noise, you might receive a threatening letter accusing you of harassing other residents. (Note: The sundeck was closed for construction during my first year but reopened last summer.)3. Pest Problems: During my first year, there were hardly any pests. However, last summer, I began seeing large ones, followed by frequent small bugs and flies. Some can even be spotted in the basement.4. Street Noise: If possible, avoid apartments facing the street, though most of them do. The trash truck from the Metro Diner makes loud noise every night around 1-2 a.m. If you’re a light sleeper, be prepared for disrupted sleep.5. Disrespectful Treatment: If you are a young Asian female, be prepared to be treated with disrespect and a belittling attitude by the managers. The way the two male managers speak to you is not like addressing a customer, but more like speaking to "a little girl”6. Most of the maintenance workers I’ve encountered in the building over the past years have been very kind and helpful. However, I must note that some of them seem to be heavily exploited, working excessively long hours with little to no rest. I’m not entirely sure if their working conditions are fully legal.
February 08 · D L
Lived in Whitehall for 2 years while at Columbia and loved it. Was really affordable compared to other similar Apt buildings in the neighborhood, clean (no pests) and overall very helpful.I would recommend it if you re a student!Especially for international students, they don’t have strict policies for moving in with credit checks, etc
August 11 · Alexia Rempoutzakou
Lived in Whitehall for 2 years while at Columbia and loved it. Was really affordable compared to other similar Apt buildings in the neighborhood, clean (no pests) and overall very helpful.I would recommend it if you re a student!Especially for international students, they don’t have strict policies for moving in with credit checks, etc
August 11 · Alexia Rempoutzakou
Horrible and terrible living experience. I’ve been out for a long day and there’s no hot water to take a shower. I called the front desk and he told me he will send the super upstairs. However nobody showed up and the front desk yelled at me and said he has hot water, complaining me making him wake up the maintenance guy. He said he is gonna send the guy up but nobody shows up. The question is, when can I take a shower? What is the apartment that you can’t even take a shower? Is this place ever a place that you can live?
April 07 · Runmeng Xu
Horrible and terrible living experience. I’ve been out for a long day and there’s no hot water to take a shower. I called the front desk and he told me he will send the super upstairs. However nobody showed up and the front desk yelled at me and said he has hot water, complaining me making him wake up the maintenance guy. He said he is gonna send the guy up but nobody shows up. The question is, when can I take a shower? What is the apartment that you can’t even take a shower? Is this place ever a place that you can live?
April 07 · Runmeng Xu
Renting an apartment in NYC is always expensive. That being said, I lived here for two years and I loved my experience. The door men, shout out to Josh for being so helpful, we’re kind. The maintenance crew were also very helpful and were always there when I needed help.The only downside about the apartment building is the noise. Since it’s on Broadway there will be noisy nights but I feel that’s everywhere in NYC. Overall, it’s a great place to live.
September 29 · MA
Renting an apartment in NYC is always expensive. That being said, I lived here for two years and I loved my experience. The door men, shout out to Josh for being so helpful, we’re kind. The maintenance crew were also very helpful and were always there when I needed help.The only downside about the apartment building is the noise. Since it’s on Broadway there will be noisy nights but I feel that’s everywhere in NYC. Overall, it’s a great place to live.
September 29 · MA
Horrible management. All the workers are cut throat people. Take your money elsewhere.
April 07 · Lorenzo Rivera
Horrible management. All the workers are cut throat people. Take your money elsewhere.
April 07 · Lorenzo Rivera