The Carteret Introduce
In the heart of New York City's vibrant Chelsea neighborhood, a classic pre-war building stands as a testament to timeless architecture and prime urban living. The Carteret, located at 208 West 23rd Street, is an elegant apartment building that has been a fixture of the area since its construction in 1927. Originally designed by renowned architect Emery Roth, the building has since been converted into a residential apartment building, offering a mix of studio, one-bedroom, and two-bedroom homes. The building is managed by the Brodsky Organization, a well-known name in New York real estate, which oversees the property's ongoing operations and renovations.
The Carteret provides a quintessential New York living experience, combining the charm of a pre-war structure with the conveniences of modern living. While some apartments have been fully renovated with contemporary finishes and stainless steel appliances, others retain a more classic feel and are available at a discounted price. This variety caters to a range of tastes and budgets, all within a building that offers a suite of sought-after amenities. The Carteret's history is as unique as its architecture, having once been a "skyscraper church" and later a hotel before its conversion to residential apartments. This rich past contributes to its distinct character and appeal.
As with any high-traffic residential building in a dense urban environment, living at The Carteret has its ups and downs, which is reflected in some of the public reviews. Feedback suggests that the building has experienced some changes over the years, particularly in its tenant demographics. However, many residents highlight the professionalism and helpfulness of the staff, particularly the concierges and doormen, as a significant positive. The on-site superintendent and management by the reputable Brodsky Organization are key factors in maintaining the building's operations and addressing resident concerns.
The Carteret is situated at 208 W 23rd St, New York, NY 10011, USA. This address places it in the epicenter of the lively Chelsea neighborhood, known for its art galleries, dining, and nightlife. The location offers residents unparalleled accessibility to the rest of the city. The building is just a short walk from major subway lines, including the 1, 2, 3, A, C, E, F, and M trains, making commuting a breeze. It is also within walking distance of popular destinations like The High Line, Chelsea Piers, and Chelsea Market, offering an abundance of recreational and social opportunities right at the doorstep.
The building's accessibility features include a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring that it can accommodate residents and visitors with mobility needs. The central location also means that a variety of services and transportation options are just a stone's throw away. While street parking is an option, it is typically paid and limited, which is common for this area of Manhattan. The prime location and excellent transit connections make The Carteret an ideal choice for those who value convenience and easy access to the best that New York City has to offer.
Services Offered:
- Apartment rentals: Offering a range of rental units from studios to two-bedrooms.
- Onsite services: Providing a variety of services directly on the premises for resident convenience.
- Doorman and Concierge Services: A doorman is available to assist with a variety of needs, and public reviews praise the service of the concierges.
- On-site superintendent: A live-in super is available to handle maintenance and building-related issues.
- Laundry facilities: The building features laundry facilities for residents' use.
- Pet-friendly policies: The building welcomes pets, which is a key consideration for many New Yorkers.
Features and Highlights:
- Located in the highly desirable and vibrant Chelsea neighborhood.
- A classic pre-war building with elegant architectural details and a rich history.
- Managed by the well-known Brodsky Organization, a reputable real estate developer and manager.
- Offers a variety of apartment layouts, including renovated units with modern finishes and appliances.
- Boasts a private and stunning rooftop terrace with expansive views of the city.
- Features a modern fitness center with cardio machines and free weights.
- The building is equipped with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, ensuring inclusivity.
- Offers amenities such as elevators, doorman service, and an on-site superintendent for a high level of convenience and security.
Contact Information:
For more information on available apartments or to schedule a visit, you can contact The Carteret's leasing team:
Address: 208 W 23 St, New York, NY 10011, USA
Phone: (212) 929-7060
What is worth choosing:
For a prospective tenant, choosing an apartment building in New York City is about balancing location, amenities, and community. What is worth choosing about The Carteret is its undeniable prestige and prime location. The building's address on West 23rd Street in Chelsea places it in one of the city's most exciting and walkable neighborhoods, with a high "Walker's Paradise" score. The proximity to parks, cultural landmarks, and a wide array of dining and entertainment options is a major advantage that enhances the quality of life for residents.
Furthermore, the presence of a professional staff, including a doorman and concierge team, is a significant plus. The review from a resident who praised the "incredible" concierges like Gene and Howard highlights a key strength of the building—the human element. A helpful and friendly staff can make a substantial difference in a resident's daily experience, from managing packages to providing a sense of security and community. While some public reviews have raised concerns about tenant noise and a serious past incident, these issues should be carefully considered against the building's overall reputation, its high-end amenities like the rooftop terrace and gym, and the management by a reputable firm like the Brodsky Organization. For those who prioritize a classic New York location with key luxury amenities and professional on-site services, The Carteret remains a compelling choice.
The Carteret Details
Service options
- Onsite services
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
The Carteret Photos










The Carteret Location
The Carteret Reviews
building
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Concierge are incredible (Gene and Howard are the best in NYC), the apartment I rented was fully renovated except they forgot to install ventilation in the kitchen above the stove and refused to do so after I signed. One star for the way Brodsky treated the Asian American woman being attack violently outside the building (look it up, from 2021 - they closed the door on her as she was being kicked in the gut on the ground). Wouldn’t ever want to live here again for fear of personal safety. Rents also dropped a lot after COVID which introduced problematic tenants.
July 08 · Karen NIt’s my third year here and I’m leaving once my lease is up. First two years were great- good doorman, good management, good super, good neighbors, clean and QUIET. Ever since COVID, the rent dropped significantly which attracted younger crowds in early-mid 20s and it has gone downhill. Noise level is poorly managed- loud parties after midnight (no masks of course), stomping on the floor, using vacuum/blender at 4-5AM, slamming the door at late nights, and more. It’s like living in dorm all over again.
February 13 · A KI love the location and the staff is friendly (mostly) but the price is ridiculous for what they offer. It's $2500 for a 190 sq ft studio. The biggest issue is that the water is always being shut off for emergency maintenance. The building is old and the plumbing sucks. I had to had my toilet removed and fixed twice within the first few months of living here. The maintenance guys got here quickly and helped but the toilet was backing up into the bath. It was pretty rancid. The bathroom always smells weird no matter how much I clean it and I have to assume its the plumbing issues. There are also not enough washers/dryers since everyone is moving back to the city. It was fine during COVID but when the building is more filled there is truly never washer or dryer space and you always have to wait. It was a good place to live during COVID because the rent was $800 cheaper but I would never pay full price.
September 24 · Kaleigh BoothClassic
April 16 · Alfredo Plessmann IIIAmazing staff!
February 16 · Christine Donnantuono
More Real Estate Agency Near Me

160 W 24 St, New York, NY 10011, USA

138 W 25th St Suite 801/802, New York, NY 10001, USA

159 W 25th St Floors 4, 5, 7 & 8, New York, NY 10001, USA

130 W 25th St 5th fl, New York, NY 10001, USA

135 W 27th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

130 W 25th St Suite 5A, New York, NY 10001, USA

250 W 26th St Suite 405, New York, NY 10001, USA

291 7th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

158 W 27th St Floor 7, New York, NY 10001, USA

71 W 23 St #1001, New York, NY 10010, USA

122 W 27th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

307 7th Ave Suite 1406, New York, NY 10001, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Estate Agency Blog Posts





